Skip to main content
I'm a …
Call UsGet Started

Foreign Tax Credit vs Foreign Earned Income Exclusion: What to Use for Americans in the UK?

Foreign Tax Credit vs Foreign Earned Income Exclusion for US expats in the UK: which cuts your US tax, what FEIE costs in child credits and the 5-year lock.

young woman filing uk taxes on her laptop

The Foreign Earned Income Exclusion and the Foreign Tax Credit are two different reliefs for the same problem: being taxed by both the US and the UK on the same income. You choose between them for each slice of income, and you cannot claim both on the same dollar. The exclusion, claimed on Form 2555, takes foreign earned income out of your US gross income, up to $130,000 for tax year 2025 and $132,900 for tax year 2026. The credit, claimed on Form 1116, reduces your US tax by the foreign income tax you have already paid. For most Americans employed in the UK, the credit gives the better result, because the UK usually taxes a salary more heavily than the US does. The main exception is a basic-rate taxpayer with US-citizen children, where the exclusion can cost more than it saves.

Three situations cover most UK readers, and each turns on a different part of the comparison:

  • Employed in the UK, taxed at the higher rate. You have probably paid more UK tax on your salary than the US would charge on it, which is the case the credit is built for.
  • Employed at the UK basic rate, with US-citizen children. The exclusion can remove your US tax and your access to the refundable additional child tax credit along with it.
  • A salary above the exclusion limit, plus UK dividends, interest or rental profit. The exclusion never reaches unearned income, so the credit is doing work on your return whatever you decide about the salary.

Key takeaways

  • Default to the Foreign Tax Credit if the UK taxes your salary at 40%. The UK higher rate starts at £50,271 for 2026 to 2027, well below the $130,000 and $132,900 exclusion limits, so a salary that fits inside the exclusion can still carry more UK tax than the US would charge on it.
  • Treat surplus UK tax as an asset, not a loss. Unused credit carries back one year and forward up to ten years within the same income category. An unused exclusion leaves you nothing.
  • Price the refundable child credit before you claim the exclusion. The additional child tax credit and the earned income credit are both unavailable for any year you exclude foreign earned income, and on a basic-rate UK salary with two or three US-citizen children that forgone credit can exceed the US tax the exclusion saved.
  • Claim the credit on your UK dividends, interest and rental profit whatever you decide about the salary. The exclusion reaches earned income only, so unearned income sits outside it and the UK tax on it stays creditable.
  • Treat a move from the exclusion to the credit as a five-year decision. Taking a credit on income you could have excluded revokes the election from that year, and reclaiming the same exclusion inside five tax years needs IRS approval and a fee.
  • Do not reach for either relief to cut a self-employment tax bill. The exclusion reduces income tax only, and the credit is a credit against income tax, so neither one moves what you owe in self-employment tax.
  • Compute the return both ways and compare three numbers, not one. The US tax owed, the refundable credits available to you and the foreign tax credit carried forward: the headline tax figure on its own hides what the exclusion costs elsewhere.

FEIE vs Foreign Tax Credit at a glance

The two reliefs differ on what they do, what income they reach, what they leave behind for future years, and what else on your return they damage.

What you are comparingForeign Earned Income Exclusion (Form 2555)Foreign Tax Credit (Form 1116)
What it does to your US taxRemoves qualifying foreign earned income from US gross incomeGives a credit against US tax for foreign income tax already paid or accrued
The form you fileForm 2555, attached to Form 1040Form 1116, attached to Form 1040
How much it coversUp to $130,000 of foreign earned income for tax year 2025 and $132,900 for tax year 2026, per qualifying personNo dollar cap, but limited by the US tax attributable to your foreign-source income
Which income it reachesForeign earned income only: wages, salary, professional fees and self-employment income for services performed abroadForeign income taxes on earned and unearned income alike, including UK dividends, interest and rental profits
Who it usually suitsPeople in low-tax or no-tax countries, where there is little foreign tax to creditPeople in countries that tax the same income at or above the US rate, which includes the UK at higher and additional rates
What happens to relief you cannot use this yearNothing carries over; an unused exclusion is simply goneUnused credit carries back one year and then forward up to ten years, within the same income category
Effect on the refundable child creditThe additional child tax credit cannot be taken if you claim the exclusionNo effect; the credit leaves your earned income in place
Effect on the earned income creditYou do not qualify for the earned income credit for a year in which you exclude foreign earned incomeNo effect
Effect on self-employment taxNone: the exclusion reduces income tax and does not reduce self-employment taxNone: the credit is a credit against income tax
How hard it is to undoThe election continues for later years until revoked, and after a revocation you cannot claim the same exclusion for the next five tax years without IRS approvalYou choose the credit year by year, with no multi-year lock

What does each one actually do to your US tax bill?

The exclusion changes the income side of your return; the credit changes the tax side. The law also stops you using both on the same dollar: once you exclude income, the foreign tax on that income can no longer be credited. Because the two reliefs work at different points on the return, each one interacts differently with everything else on it.

The Foreign Earned Income Exclusion takes income out of the calculation

The Foreign Earned Income Exclusion lets you leave qualifying foreign earned income out of your US gross income, and you claim it on Form 2555. It is voluntary: nothing happens unless you complete the relevant parts of that form. It reaches foreign earned income only, which, according to the IRS, means wages, salaries, professional fees and other amounts paid for personal services you performed abroad.

The exclusion is capped, and the cap is set per qualifying person for each tax year:

Tax yearMaximum foreign earned income exclusion, per qualifying person
2025$130,000
2026$132,900

To qualify, your tax home must be in a foreign country, which broadly means your main place of work is abroad, and you must also pass one of two tests. The bona fide residence test asks whether you have been a genuine resident of a foreign country for an uninterrupted period that includes a full tax year. The physical presence test asks whether you were in foreign countries for at least 330 full days in any 12-month period. Excluding the income does not excuse you from filing. You still file the US return, and you claim the exclusion on it.

The Foreign Tax Credit gives you credit for tax you already paid

The Foreign Tax Credit gives you a credit against your US tax for foreign income taxes you paid or accrued, and you claim it on Form 1116. Two features of it decide most of this comparison.

a person working at a table, writing notes in a book

First, it reaches foreign income taxes on unearned income as well as on salary, so UK tax on dividends, interest and rental profits counts too. Second, it has no dollar cap. Instead, the credit cannot exceed the US tax on your foreign-source income: in rough terms, your US tax multiplied by the share of your taxable income that comes from abroad. Only income taxes count, so UK National Insurance contributions cannot be credited. The credit also offsets regular income tax only. Under US domestic law it does not reduce the 3.8% Net Investment Income Tax that can apply to investment income of higher earners. Even so, the IRS's own position is that taking foreign income taxes as a credit is, in most cases, to your advantage.

The exclusion does not lower the tax rate on your other income

Claiming the exclusion does not reset your US tax rates. You work out the tax on your remaining income using the Foreign Earned Income Tax Worksheet in the Form 1040 instructions. That worksheet applies the rates that would have applied if you had excluded nothing. So the excluded income leaves your taxable income, but it still sets the rate on what is left.

Important: the first dollar above the exclusion is not taxed at the lowest US rate. It is taxed as though the excluded amount were still sitting underneath it, which is why a salary a little above the limit produces more US tax than the headline exclusion figure suggests.

Why the Foreign Tax Credit usually beats the exclusion in the UK

The UK taxes employment income at rates that reach 40% well below the exclusion limit, so a UK-employed American usually has more UK tax paid than US tax owed on the same salary. That is the situation the foreign tax credit is built for, and it is why the credit is the usual answer here.

The arithmetic behind that is the gap between the two rate ladders. With a standard Personal Allowance of £12,570, UK income tax for 2026 to 2027 runs through three rates. These are the bands for England, Wales and Northern Ireland. Scotland sets its own bands, and its higher rates start at lower incomes.

BandTaxable income, 2026 to 2027UK income tax rate
Personal AllowanceUp to £12,5700%
Basic rate£12,571 to £50,27020%
Higher rate£50,271 to £125,14040%
Additional rateAbove £125,14045%

US federal income tax for 2026 runs through seven rates, from 10% to 37%. The UK higher rate of 40% starts at £50,271 of taxable income. Even after converting pounds to dollars, that is far below the $130,000 and $132,900 exclusion limits. So a salary can sit comfortably inside the exclusion limit and still be taxed by the UK at 40%.

The UK rate climbs further for salaries above £100,000. Your Personal Allowance falls by £1 for every £2 of adjusted net income above that level, so income between £100,000 and £125,140 is effectively taxed at 60%. The exclusion is designed for the opposite case: a country that charges little or no tax, which leaves little foreign tax to credit.

Example: Rachel, employed in London

Rachel is a US citizen employed in London on a salary of £62,000, with no children, no self-employment income and no US-source income. For 2026 to 2027 her UK income tax is about £12,200, because the top £11,730 of her salary falls in the 40% band. At an assumed exchange rate of $1.34 to the pound, that is roughly $16,400. Her US federal income tax on the same salary for 2026, after the $16,100 standard deduction, would be roughly $9,400. Taking the credit clears that $9,400 using UK tax she has already paid, and the remaining $6,900 or so can be carried back or forward. Taking the exclusion would also leave her owing no US tax, but nothing would carry over, because an unused exclusion produces nothing for a later year. These figures are a rounded illustration; her actual result depends on the exchange rate used and the rest of her return.

Caution: a UK basic-rate taxpayer on a modest salary is a different case, and so is anyone with children or self-employment income on the return. The next two sections deal with both.

Can you use the Foreign Tax Credit and the FEIE together in the same year?

Yes, on different income. What you cannot do is apply both to the same dollar. If you claim the exclusion, the foreign tax on the excluded portion is lost to you, but you can still credit the foreign tax on income above the exclusion and on income the exclusion never reached.

The rule comes straight from the election. Once you choose to exclude foreign earned income or foreign housing costs, you cannot take a foreign tax credit or deduction for the taxes on income you excluded or could have excluded. The foreign housing exclusion is a companion relief that lets you exclude part of your housing costs abroad above a set base amount. The same IRS page confirms the other half of the rule: you can still take a credit on foreign earned income above the amounts you excluded.

Where only part of your foreign earned income is excluded, the UK tax on it has to be split. The usual method is a ratio: the UK tax on that income multiplied by the excluded income, divided by your total foreign earned income, with each figure taken after the deductions that relate to it. The share that matches the excluded income cannot be credited or deducted. This split follows automatically from the exclusion; it is not a choice you make afterwards. Income the exclusion never reaches is simpler. Because the exclusion covers foreign earned income only, UK dividends, interest, rental profits and capital gains sit outside it, and the UK tax on them can be credited whatever you do about your salary.

Splitting a return follows three steps in order:

  1. Exclude the qualifying foreign earned income you are claiming, up to the limit for the year.
  2. Identify the foreign tax allocable to that excluded part and set it aside, because none of it is creditable or deductible.
  3. Credit the foreign tax on everything else: the earned income above the exclusion, and all of your unearned income.

Example: Priya, employed in Manchester

Priya is a US citizen living in Manchester with a UK salary of £150,000 and £9,000 of UK dividends. She claims the exclusion on her salary. Once converted to dollars, her salary is well above the exclusion limit for the year, so the UK tax on the slice above the limit can still be credited. Her dividends sit outside the exclusion entirely, so the UK tax on them can be credited whether or not she claims the exclusion. The part she loses is the UK tax allocable to the excluded slice of her salary: it produces no credit and no deduction on her US return.

What does claiming the exclusion cost you elsewhere on your return?

Four things. You lose the refundable child credit and the earned income credit for that year. You may lose the compensation your IRA contribution depends on. You keep your self-employment tax in full. And you give up any credit for the UK tax on the income you excluded. For a UK family with children, these costs can outweigh what the exclusion saves.

You lose the additional child tax credit and the earned income credit

The additional child tax credit is the refundable part of the US child tax credit, which means it can be paid to you even when you owe no US tax. For 2025 and 2026 it is worth up to $1,700 per qualifying child, calculated as 15% of your earned income above $2,500. It is unavailable for any year in which you exclude foreign earned income, and the IRS applies the same bar to the earned income credit. For a UK family this is the trap. The exclusion looks free because it wipes out the US tax on a basic-rate salary, but the refundable credit for two or three children can be worth more than the US tax the exclusion saved. The credit route avoids this, because your earned income stays on the return.

Example: Daniel, teaching in Leeds

Daniel is a US citizen teaching in Leeds on a UK salary of £29,000, taxed by the UK at the basic rate of 20%. He files jointly with his wife, who is also a US citizen, and they have two US-citizen children, both with Social Security numbers. His salary sits comfortably inside the exclusion limit, so the exclusion would remove his US tax on it. It would also block the additional child tax credit for that year, which could be worth up to $3,400 to the family ($1,700 for each child). If he claims the foreign tax credit instead, the UK tax he has paid can still clear his US tax, and the refundable credit stays available. This is the case where a low UK rate and US-citizen children pull in opposite directions.

It can reduce how much you can contribute to an IRA

Claiming the exclusion can reduce, or even remove, the amount you are allowed to pay into an IRA, because you can only contribute up to the amount of your compensation for the year. The IRS gives two different answers on whether excluded income counts as compensation, so both are set out here. The IRS page for international taxpayers says that if you exclude income under the foreign earned income exclusion or the foreign housing exclusion, you add the excluded amounts back when working out your compensation for the IRA limits. Publication 590-A says the opposite. It lists amounts you exclude from income, such as foreign earned income and housing costs, as items that are not compensation for IRA purposes.

The two sources agree on one point. When you work out modified adjusted gross income for the traditional IRA deduction limits, you add the exclusion back. So the exclusion can push you over a phase-out even on the more generous reading. The foreign tax credit avoids this question, because your earned income stays on the return.

Caution: on the more generous reading, your excluded salary still counts as compensation and your contribution stands. On the Publication 590-A reading it does not, and a contribution made on that basis is an excess contribution, which attracts a 6% penalty for each year it stays in the account. If your IRA contribution depends on which reading applies, take advice before you contribute.

It does not reduce your self-employment tax

The exclusion reduces regular income tax only, so it leaves your self-employment tax untouched. Switching to the credit does not help either, because the credit offsets income tax, not self-employment tax. So for a US citizen running a business in the UK, neither relief solves a self-employment tax bill. What does solve it is the US-UK Social Security Agreement, which the IRS calls a totalization agreement. Under it, a self-employed person who lives in the UK is normally covered only by UK National Insurance. To stop paying US self-employment tax, you need a certificate of coverage from HMRC, and you attach a statement to your US return. Our guide to US expat taxes in the UK covers this in more detail.

You lose the credit for UK tax on the income you exclude

The foreign tax on excluded income can be neither credited nor deducted. Where only part of your income is excluded, the foreign tax allocable to the excluded part is lost in the same way. For a UK higher-rate taxpayer this is the largest hidden cost of the exclusion. The UK tax you already paid on the excluded slice produces nothing on your US return, this year or in any later year.

What happens to foreign tax credits you cannot use this year?

Unused foreign tax credits do not disappear. If the foreign tax you paid or accrued for a year is more than your foreign tax credit limit for that year, the IRS lets you carry the unused amount back one year and then forward for up to ten years. The carryback comes first, and only what is left after it moves forward. Our guide to foreign tax credit carryovers on Form 1116 explains the mechanics.

Two conditions limit how you can use a carryover. First, it stays in the income category where it arose. UK tax on your salary falls in the general category, so it cannot be used against the limit for passive income such as dividends and interest.

Second, you can only use it in a year that has spare room under the limit for that category. That means a year where your US tax on foreign income is higher than the foreign tax you paid on it. The exclusion offers nothing like this: an exclusion you do not use in a year produces nothing you can carry anywhere.

A carryforward is worth having because those years do come along:

  • A year with US-source or other non-UK income, which creates US tax the carryover can reach.
  • A year of lower UK tax, such as a career break, a period out of work or a move away from the UK.
  • A year with income the UK does not tax at the same rate as the US does.

This is the part of the comparison that a single year's tax figure does not show. UK tax above your US liability is banked rather than wasted, and only the credit banks it.

Switching between the exclusion and the credit: the five-year rule

The two reliefs are not symmetrical here. The credit is chosen year by year. The exclusion, once elected, continues into later years until you revoke it, and a revocation locks you out of that same exclusion for the next five tax years unless the IRS approves an earlier return to it.

The election is not an annual decision. Once made, it applies to that year and every later year until you revoke it. A choice made in your first UK tax year therefore carries forward on its own until you act.

stressed man reviewing his tax bills and feeling concerned in his office

To revoke deliberately, you attach a statement to the return or amended return for the first year you do not wish to claim the exclusion, naming which choice you are revoking. The foreign earned income exclusion and the foreign housing exclusion are revoked separately.

If you then want the same exclusion back within five tax years, you must ask the IRS for approval by requesting a ruling, and the IRS charges a fee for it. When deciding, the IRS looks at facts such as a period of residence in the United States, a move to another foreign country with different tax rates, a substantial change in the tax laws of your country of residence, or a change of employer. The Form 2555 instructions set out the same five-year rule.

A revocation can also happen without you writing anything. Claiming a foreign tax credit or deduction for taxes on income you could have excluded revokes the election from the year of that claim. Publication 54 treats claiming the additional child tax credit or the earned income credit in a later year in the same way.

Important: the switch most people make, from the exclusion to the credit on the same salary, is itself a revocation. You do not sign anything and you may not notice it in the year you do it. The cost arrives later, when you want the exclusion back and find the five-year clock running.

That asymmetry is what makes the exclusion the heavier of the two commitments. If your UK circumstances may change, through children, a salary crossing the limit, a move or a period back in the United States, the credit keeps every year's decision open while the exclusion ties several of them together.

The mistakes that cost UK-based Americans the most

Almost every expensive error comes from treating the exclusion as the default because it is simpler, and from not looking at the rest of the return before choosing.

“My UK salary fits inside the exclusion limit, so the exclusion is the one for me.” Fitting inside the limit tells you nothing about which relief leaves you with less US tax. The UK rate on that salary decides it. If you act on this belief, you can waste UK tax that would have cleared your US bill and left a carryforward for later years.

“The exclusion zeroes out my US tax, so my family is better off.” The additional child tax credit cannot be taken for any year in which you exclude foreign earned income, and the earned income credit goes with it. For a basic-rate UK taxpayer with two or three US-citizen children, the refundable credit forgone can be worth more than the US tax the exclusion saved.

“Anything above the exclusion is taxed from the bottom US rate up.” Tax on your remaining income uses the rates that would have applied if you had excluded nothing. The first dollar above the exclusion is taxed as though the excluded amount were still underneath it. Budget on the lowest rate and the US bill on that slice will be higher than you expect.

“I paid UK tax on the whole salary, so I can credit the UK tax on the excluded part too.” The foreign tax on income you excluded, or could have excluded, is neither creditable nor deductible, and where only part of the income is excluded, the tax allocable to that part goes with it. The UK tax on the excluded slice produces nothing on your US return, now or later.

“I'll just take the credit this year instead.” Taking a foreign tax credit or deduction for taxes on income you could have excluded revokes the election from the year of that claim. You can be five tax years away from the exclusion without having filed a statement or intended to give it up.

“One of these will bring down my self-employment tax.” The exclusion reduces regular income tax only, and the credit only offsets income tax. Choosing between them does nothing for a self-employment tax bill. For a UK resident, the US-UK Social Security Agreement is the route that matters.

“The foreign tax credit on my US return and the one on my Self Assessment are the same relief.” They are two separate reliefs in two tax systems. The US credit is claimed on Form 1116 against US tax. The UK's Foreign Tax Credit Relief is claimed on your Self Assessment return against UK tax. Treating them as one leads people to assume a claim made in one country has been dealt with in the other.

Frequently asked questions

Is the foreign tax credit refundable?

No. It is a credit against US tax, so it can reduce your US liability but it does not generate a refund of its own. Where the foreign tax exceeds what you can credit this year, the excess carries back one year and forward up to ten, as set out above.

Do I still report my UK income on Form 1040 if I claim the exclusion?

Yes. Both reliefs operate on a return that already reports your worldwide income, and neither removes the filing obligation. The exclusion is claimed on Form 2555 attached to that return, and the credit on Form 1116.

Does the exclusion cover my UK dividends, interest or rental income?

No. The exclusion reaches foreign earned income only, meaning compensation for services you performed. UK dividends, interest, rental profits and capital gains sit outside it, which is why the foreign tax credit is the only one of the two reliefs that reaches them.

Which form do I file for each one?

Form 2555 for the Foreign Earned Income Exclusion and Form 1116 for the Foreign Tax Credit, both attached to Form 1040. A return can carry both forms in the same year where the two reliefs are applied to different income, as set out above.

Should I run my return both ways before deciding?

If you have children, self-employment income, an IRA contribution or income above the exclusion limit, yes. The two reliefs reach different parts of the return, so the headline US tax figure is not the whole comparison. Compare three things across both versions: the US tax owed, the refundable credits available to you, and the foreign tax credit carried forward.

Get help choosing between the Foreign Tax Credit and the FEIE

Help with the Foreign Tax Credit and the FEIE starts with computing the return both ways, for the same year, before you make or revoke an election.

Cross-border tax is easier with one team on both sides

Tell us your situation, with no obligation, and we’ll show you what you need to file in the US and the UK, and what it costs, up front.

an image of global map and calculators